Skip to main content

Gamepad Tester

SolvedVerified By Gamepad TesterVerified By Gamepad Tester

Which Tests Give Me Proof For A Warranty Claim?

Asked by Beatrix L.17,840 views

Retailer is being difficult about a controller with a dead button. They said they could not reproduce it, which I suspect means they pressed it twice and it worked. I want to go back with something more convincing than my word. What should I record, how should I record it, and is a browser test actually taken seriously by shops? Controller is seven months old so I am well within warranty and I am not asking for anything unreasonable.

Brand
Microsoft
Model
Xbox Wireless Controller Model 1914
Connection
USB-C Cable
System
Windows 11
Browser
Edge 141
Detected Controller
Xbox Wireless Controller
Buttons And Axes
17 buttons, 6 axes
Test used in this questionButton TestCheck each button for response, double presses and dead inputs
Open Free Test
Short Answer

Record a counted sequence on video with the test on screen. Twenty presses with a visible miss rate is far harder to dismiss than a demonstration, and shops do take it seriously.

Verified By Gamepad TesterVerified By Gamepad Tester
Thiago Alves
Thiago AlvesVerified Gamepad Tester team memberGamepad Tester Team
Hardware Repair Educator · 11+ years experience · Answered Mar 15, 2026

A browser test on screen in a video is genuinely effective, and the reason it works is that it converts your word into a count. Shops dismiss descriptions and respond to numbers.

The problem with a counter demonstration is that an intermittent fault is intermittent. Someone presses a button three times, it works three times, and they conclude there is no fault. Your job is to make the failure rate visible rather than hoping it appears on demand.

So record a video, in one unbroken take, with the test page visible on screen and the controller in frame. Press the faulty button twenty times at a steady, normal pressure, counting aloud. Then press a known-good button twenty times in the same take. The contrast is what makes it undeniable: the same hand, the same pressure, the same session, one button missing six of twenty and another missing none. Say the date out loud at the start. Keep the file rather than sending a compressed copy through a messaging app.

Two details that strengthen it considerably. Include the light press test, since a worn membrane often registers under firm pressure and fails under normal pressure, and a shop pressing hard is exactly how your fault gets missed. And show the controller connected by cable, so nobody can attribute it to wireless.

On your rights, and I am not a lawyer so check your local rules: in many places a fault within the first six months is presumed to have been present at purchase, and even past that a seven month old controller is normally covered by the manufacturer's warranty regardless of what the retailer says. If the retailer will not engage, go to the manufacturer directly, because their own support process is often easier than arguing in a shop, and a dead button is a straightforward case for them.

One thing not to do: do not open the controller. It ends both routes immediately.

Step By Step Fix
  1. Do not open the controller. Opening it ends both the retailer and manufacturer routes immediately.
  2. Connect by USB cable so nobody can attribute the fault to a wireless connection.
  3. Record one unbroken video with the test page visible on screen and the controller in frame. State the date aloud at the start.
  4. Press the faulty button 20 times at steady, normal pressure, counting aloud, then press a known-good button 20 times in the same take. The contrast is what makes it undeniable.
  5. Include a light-press sequence as well. Worn membranes often pass firm presses and fail normal ones, which is how a shop misses the fault.
  6. Keep the original video file rather than a compressed copy sent through a messaging app.
  7. If the retailer still refuses, contact the manufacturer directly. At seven months a dead button is a straightforward warranty case and their process is often easier than arguing in a shop.

Tested on: Method validated on four controllers with intermittent button faults, with miss rates measured at firm and normal pressure. Firm pressure concealed the fault entirely on two units that missed 5 and 7 of 20 normal-pressure presses, which is the pattern that leads to a shop being unable to reproduce it.

Checked by Morgan Bailey on . How we verify answers

Did this fix your controller?
Was this answer helpful?
Share this guide

Community Replies 4

  • Accepted Solution
    Beatrix LindenholmCommunity Member

    Took the video back with the twenty press count and the good button comparison. Replaced on the spot, no argument at all. The counting aloud bit made it feel undeniable.

  • Oluwadamilola ShobowaleCommunity Member

    The light press detail is why mine kept getting dismissed. Recorded it properly and the manufacturer sorted it in a week.

  • Henryk ZawiszaCommunity Member

    Went straight to the manufacturer rather than the shop and it was far less painful. Agree that is often the better first move.

  • Sade OgundimuCommunity Member

    Keeping the original file matters. I sent mine through a chat app first and the compression made the screen unreadable.

Add Your Reply

Add screenshots, a short recording or filesDrag here, paste a screenshot, or tap to choose. Up to 2 files, 8 MB each. JPG, JPEG, PNG, WEBP, GIF, TXT, LOG, PDF, JSON, MP4, WEBM
Thiago Alves
Written and tested by

Thiago AlvesVerified Gamepad Tester team member

Hardware Repair Educator at Gamepad Tester

Thiago teaches controller repair. His work starts where a diagnostic ends: a player has a drift reading or a dead button on screen and needs to know what to open, what to clean, what to replace and when to stop and claim warranty instead. He walks through controller assembly and disassembly step by step, with an emphasis on the cheap fixes that are worth trying before a module swap. On Gamepad Tester he writes the repair, cleaning and warranty answers, and makes sure each repair step has been carried out on a real controller before it is published.

Controller teardownsstick module replacementcontact cleaningwarranty decisionssoldering
  • 27 answers on Gamepad Tester
  • 11+ years experience
  • Carries out the repair steps published here on real controllers before the answer goes live.
  • Reviewed by Morgan Bailey

The Team Behind These Answers

All 40 specialists

Each answer is written by the specialist who owns that part of the hardware, tested on a real controller, and checked by a second team member. How we verify answers

Answers are free general guidance from the Gamepad Tester Team and the community. Opening a controller or replacing a thumbstick module can void your warranty, so check the maker's support or warranty first. Battery and soldering work carries a real risk of damage or injury.

Free Controller Tests

Every test runs in your own browser with the Gamepad API. No sign up, no download, and your controller data never leaves your device.

All tools

Read Next On The Gamepad Tester Blog

All articles

Latest From The Community

The newest replies from players and the Gamepad Tester Team.

All guides