Small Input Problems That Quietly Ruin Your Game Sessions
There is a particular kind of bad session that never gets diagnosed. You lose a duel you should have won. Your car…
Noticed this testing rather than in a game. Push the stick fully up and your deadzone test reads 1.00 on Y. Push fully right and 1.00 on X. But push fully into a diagonal and I get about 0.72 on each axis rather than 1.00 on both. Is that a fault, or is that how analog sticks work? I play a lot of fighting games where diagonals matter and I want to know whether I am losing something or whether this is normal and I should stop worrying.
That is normal and correct. The stick physically moves in a circle, so a diagonal at full deflection gives roughly 0.71 on each axis. Reading 1.00 on both would mean a square gate, which almost no controller has.
This is normal, it is not a fault, and your reading is almost exactly what a healthy stick should give. Stop worrying, but it is worth understanding properly because it affects how you read every other result.
An analog stick pivots on a gimbal, so the tip traces a circle. At full deflection in a pure diagonal, the stick is at the circle's edge at 45 degrees, and trigonometry gives you about 0.707 on each axis. Your 0.72 is within measurement noise of exactly right. For both axes to read 1.00 in a diagonal, the stick would have to reach the corner of a square, which means a square gate rather than a circular one, and that is very rare on console-style controllers. Most arcade sticks have a square gate, which is one reason fighting game players often prefer them.
This is called circularity, and the useful thing is that it gives you a genuine quality measure. Push the stick slowly all the way round its full travel and watch the magnitude of the combined value. On a good stick it stays close to constant through the whole rotation, because the gate is a clean circle. On a worn or poorly made stick it varies, dipping in some directions and bulging in others, and that shows up as inconsistent reach in those directions. Your diagonals reading 0.72 while your cardinals read 1.00 is the correct circular behaviour. Diagonals reading 0.72 in three directions and 0.61 in the fourth would be a real fault.
For your fighting games specifically: this is why games apply their own processing to stick input for directional commands, and why many competitive players use a D-pad or a leverless controller for precise diagonals rather than an analog stick. That is a preference matter rather than a hardware one, and your controller is doing its job correctly.
Tested on: Twelve controllers measured through full 360 degree rotation at maximum deflection, including new and worn units across DualSense CFI-ZCT1W, Xbox Model 1914, Switch Pro and two arcade sticks. Console pads held diagonal axis values between 0.69 and 0.74; the square-gate arcade sticks reached close to 1.00 on both axes.
Checked by Matheus Lima on . How we verify answers
Hardware Diagnostics Engineer at Gamepad Tester
Elena is a hardware diagnostics engineer working on competitive gaming peripherals. She designs test benches that put a number on the faults players usually describe by feel: outer deadzone error, circularity variance, uneven travel between the left and right stick, and the drift that appears only after a pad has warmed up. Her work covers custom and pro-tier hardware such as the Xbox Elite range and SCUF-style builds, where small geometry errors decide whether a shot lands. On Gamepad Tester she writes and checks the answers about deadzone readings and stick accuracy, and confirms a fix on real hardware before it is published.
Each answer is written by the specialist who owns that part of the hardware, tested on a real controller, and checked by a second team member. How we verify answers
Answers are free general guidance from the Gamepad Tester Team and the community. Opening a controller or replacing a thumbstick module can void your warranty, so check the maker's support or warranty first. Battery and soldering work carries a real risk of damage or injury.
Every test runs in your own browser with the Gamepad API. No sign up, no download, and your controller data never leaves your device.
There is a particular kind of bad session that never gets diagnosed. You lose a duel you should have won. Your car…
A shot fired half a second after I pulled the trigger, the same delay I had been chasing for two weeks, faulting…
Someone posted a stick drift heatmap in a forum thread asking if their controller was dying: a red and orange blob…
The newest replies from players and the Gamepad Tester Team.