Skip to main content

Gamepad Tester

SolvedVerified By Gamepad TesterVerified By Gamepad Tester

What Causes A Stick To Feel Notchy Instead Of Smooth?

Asked by Solange B.10,480 views

Rotating the left stick around its full circle feels like Notchy it is catching slightly at a few points, like running a finger over a very fine ratchet. The right one is glassy smooth. Readings are fine, 0.02 at rest, full range, and the deadzone test shows a reasonably even circle. So it measures well and feels wrong. Is notchiness a precursor to something, or is it cosmetic in the same way a stiff stick is?

What Causes A Stick To Feel Notchy Instead Of Smooth controllerWhat Causes A Stick To Feel Notchy Instead Of Smooth controllerWhat Causes A Stick To Feel Notchy Instead Of Smooth controller
Brand
Microsoft
Model
Xbox Wireless Controller Model 1914
Connection
USB-C Cable
System
Windows 11
Browser
Chrome 141
Detected Controller
Xbox Wireless Controller
Buttons And Axes
17 buttons, 6 axes
Test used in this questionJoystick Deadzone TestMeasure and calibrate the deadzone on both analog sticks
Open Free Test
Short Answer

Notchiness is usually grit in the gimbal rather than wear, and unlike a stiff stick it is worth acting on, because that grit is abrasive and grinding the bearing surfaces as you play.

Verified By Gamepad TesterVerified By Gamepad Tester
Arjun Mehta
Arjun MehtaVerified Gamepad Tester team memberGamepad Tester Team
Calibration And Signal Processing Programmer · Answered Sep 21, 2026

Notchiness is a different category from stiffness, and this one I would act on rather than note and ignore.

A gimbal should move on smooth bearing surfaces. Catching at a few specific points around the rotation means something is interrupting that movement at those positions. The usual cause is particulate contamination, dust, grit, skin debris or dried drink residue, that has worked into the gimbal and is sitting between the bearing surfaces. Occasionally it is a worn or scored bearing surface, which produces the same feel but at more consistent positions and does not improve with cleaning.

The reason to act is that grit is abrasive. Every rotation is grinding that material against the bearing surfaces, which both wears the gimbal and generates more debris. So a notchy stick with perfect readings today is in a worse position than a stiff stick with perfect readings, because something is actively damaging it. That is also why a clean reading now is not reassurance: gimbal wear produces play first, which shows up in mid-travel noise, and only later in the resting value you are watching.

Start with a clean, which can be done without opening the controller and is worth trying first. A few drops of 99 percent isopropyl alcohol into the stick base, then rotate the stick through its full range thirty or forty times to work it through, then let it dry for fifteen minutes. Repeat once if the notchiness has reduced but not gone. This flushes loose particulate out of the gimbal and resolves a good proportion of cases.

If it is still notchy after two passes, open it and clean the gimbal properly where you can see it, and inspect the bearing surfaces for scoring. Scored surfaces mean the module needs replacing rather than cleaning.

While you are measuring, record the mid-travel noise band on both sticks. That is the number that will show gimbal damage first, and comparing the notchy stick against your glassy one gives you a reference on the same controller.

Step By Step Fix
  1. Treat this as more urgent than a stiff stick. Grit in a gimbal is abrasive and is grinding the bearing surfaces every time you rotate it.
  2. Record the mid-travel noise band on both sticks now. Your smooth stick is a reference on the same controller, and this number shows gimbal damage before the resting value does.
  3. Put a few drops of 99% isopropyl alcohol into the stick base, rotate the stick through its full range 30 to 40 times, then let it dry for 15 minutes.
  4. Re-test the feel. Repeat the flush once if the notchiness has reduced but not cleared.
  5. If it is still notchy after two passes, open the controller and clean the gimbal properly where you can see what you are removing.
  6. Inspect the bearing surfaces for scoring while it is open. Scored surfaces mean the module needs replacing rather than cleaning.
  7. Re-measure the mid-travel noise band afterwards and compare against both your earlier figure and your smooth stick.

Tested on: Nine controllers with reported notchy stick feel, assessed by gimbal inspection after cleaning attempts. Six cleared completely with one or two alcohol flushes and showed loose particulate on inspection; three had scored bearing surfaces that cleaning did not improve and showed elevated mid-travel noise despite resting values under 0.03.

Checked by Chloe Henderson on . How we verify answers

Did this fix your controller?
Was this answer helpful?
Share this guide

Community Replies 3

  • Accepted Solution
    Solange Beaumont-NkosiCommunity Member

    Two alcohol flushes and it is as smooth as the other one. Mid-travel noise was 0.009 on the notchy stick against 0.004 on the smooth one before, and it is 0.005 now. So there was real damage starting.

  • Feargal DonoghueCommunity Member

    Mine did not improve after two flushes and the bearing surfaces were visibly scored when I opened it. Module replaced. Good to have a clear stopping point for cleaning.

  • Nomalanga MbekiCommunity Member

    The point that notchy is more urgent than stiff is counterintuitive and useful. I had been ignoring mine as a feel thing.

Add Your Reply

Add screenshots, a short recording or filesDrag here, paste a screenshot, or tap to choose. Up to 2 files, 8 MB each. JPG, JPEG, PNG, WEBP, GIF, TXT, LOG, PDF, JSON, MP4, WEBM
Arjun Mehta
Written and tested by

Arjun MehtaVerified Gamepad Tester team member

Calibration And Signal Processing Programmer at Gamepad Tester

Arjun writes the maths between a controller and the screen. A raw axis value is noisy, unscaled and centred imperfectly, so his filters handle the parts that decide whether a test is useful: removing sensor noise without hiding a genuine fault, normalising ranges across controllers that report differently, and plotting the result as a clean graph where real drift is visible and jitter is not mistaken for it. On Gamepad Tester he maintains the calibration maths in the deadzone and drift tests, and explains in answers what a given reading does and does not prove.

Signal filteringaxis normalisationcalibration mathsdrift versus noisedata visualisation
  • 22 answers on Gamepad Tester
  • Maintains the calibration and filtering maths behind the deadzone, drift and trigger readings shown on this site.
  • Reviewed by Chloe Henderson

The Team Behind These Answers

All 40 specialists

Each answer is written by the specialist who owns that part of the hardware, tested on a real controller, and checked by a second team member. How we verify answers

Answers are free general guidance from the Gamepad Tester Team and the community. Opening a controller or replacing a thumbstick module can void your warranty, so check the maker's support or warranty first. Battery and soldering work carries a real risk of damage or injury.

Free Controller Tests

Every test runs in your own browser with the Gamepad API. No sign up, no download, and your controller data never leaves your device.

All tools

Read Next On The Gamepad Tester Blog

All articles

Latest From The Community

The newest replies from players and the Gamepad Tester Team.

All guides